Defence acquisition: a wicked problem?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.33568/rbs.3302Keywords:
Defence acquisition, Wicked problem, Linear Transformation Model, Theroy-practice divide, Second generation systems approachAbstract
Defence acquisition is a complex undertaking involving multiple actors and processes. However, in recent years, the US and UK defence acquisition frameworks have been criticised for not being able to cope with the complex and uncertain nature of defence. The paper takes this criticism and argues that defence acquisition is best understood as a “wicked problem” in which collective processes tie the system into large and interconnected networks of systems, not as a traditional linear science problem. In particular, the paper demonstrates that the Linear Transformation Model, at the heart of the US and UK defence acquisition framework, is ill-designed to cope with the complex and uncertain nature of both defence outputs and outcomes. The main reasons are technological maturity, information asymmetry and the need for interpretation and judgement. Furthermore, the paper elaborates that defence acquisition is characterised by a “problem of theory” and a “problem of practice” and that further research is necessary in order to transform its institutional culture and tackle the theory-practice divide with a more holistic approach.
References
Aben, T.A.E., van der Valk, W., Roehrich, J.K. & Selviaridis, K. (2021). Managing information asymmetry in public–private relationships undergoing a digital transformation: the role of contractual and relational governance. International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 41(7). 1145-1191. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJOPM-09-2020-0675
Ahner, D., Burke, S. & Ramert, A. (2019). A system and statistical engineering enables approach for process innovation. In Badiru, A.B. & Barlow C.B. (eds.) Defense Innovation Handbook: Guidelines, Strategies, and Techniques. CRC Press.
Balakrishnan, K. (2017). The Rationale for Offsets in Defence Acquisition from a Theoretical Perspective. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.). Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Bailey R., Mazzuchi, T., Sarkani, S. & Rico, D. (2014). A Comparative Analysis of the Value of Technology Readiness Assessments. Defense Acquisition Research Journal, 21(4). 825-850.
Bellais, R. & Droff, J. (2017). Innovation, Technology, and Defence Procurement: Reform or Paradigmatic Shift? In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Bishop, D. (2017). Sector Polyarchy: How the Inherent Complexity and Risk of Defence Sector Acquisition Devours Innovation and Choice. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Brauer J. & Dunne P. (2011). Arms trade offsets: What do we know?. In Coyne C. & Mathers R. (eds.) The Handbook on the Political Economy of War. Edward Elgar.
Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (2017). Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Burgess, K. (2017). Defence Acquisition: A Practice in Need of Better Theorizing. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Calcara, A. (2018). Cooperation and conflict in the European defence-industrial field: the role of relative gains. Defence Studies, 18(4). 474-497. https://doi.org/10.1080/14702436.2018.1487766
Calcara, A. (2020). European Defence Decision-Making: Dilemmas of Collaborative Arms Procurement. Routledge.
Caldwell, N. & Howard, M. (2011). Procuring Complex Performance Studies of Innovation in Product-Service Management. Routledge.
Cochran, D. (2018). Will the Aircraft Carrier Survive? Future Air Threats to the Carrier (and How to Defend It). The Journal of the JAPCCC, 27(3). 22-28.
CRS (2022). F-35 Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) Program (RL30563). Congressional Research Service https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/details?prodcode=RL30563
Davies, G. (2021). Improving the performance of major equipment contracts (Report No HC 298.). National Audit Office. https://www.nao.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Improving-the-performance-of-major-equipment-contracts.pdf
Davies, N., Eager, A., Maier, M., & Penfold, L. (2012). Intergenerational equipment cost growth (Defence Economic Research Paper No 1). Ministry of Defence. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/280041/18_december_2012.pdf
Deming, E. W. (1982). Out of the Crisis. The MIT Press.
Department of Defense (DOD) (2021). DOD Instruction 5000.85 Major Capability Acquisition. Department of Defense. https://www.esd.whs.mil/Portals/54/Documents/DD/issuances/dodi/500085p.pdf
De France, O., Mampaey, L. & Zandee, D. (2016). Defence Industry Policy in Belgium and the Netherlands (Policy Paper No 7). Armament Industry European Research Group. https://www.iris-france.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Policy-Paper-Defence-Policy-Belgium-NL-October-2016.pdf
Director Operational Test and Evaluation (DOT&E) (2021). FY 2020 Annual Report. Director Operational Test and Evaluation. https://www.dote.osd.mil/Portals/97/pub/reports/FY2020/other/2020DOTEAnnualReport.pdf?ver=rvLsaCQ_njLmPDrNIFJBWQ%3d%3d
Ekström, T. & Dorn, M. (2014) Public Private Partnerships in Defence Acquisition. In Essig M. & Glas, A. (eds.) Performance Based Logistics: Innovatives Beschaffungsmanagement für die Streitkräfte. Springer Fachmedien.
Eliasson, G. (1990). The knowledge-based information economy. In Eliasson, G., Fölster, S., Lindberg, T., Pousette, T. & Taymaz, E. (eds.) The Knowledge Based Information Economy. IUI.
Eliasson, G. (2000). Advanced Firms as Technical Universities (Report No 4). TRITA-IEO-R. Royal Institute of Technology (KTH).
Eliasson, G. (2010). Advanced Public Procurement as Industrial Policy – Aircraft Industry as a Technical University. Springer.
Eliasson, G. (2011). The commercializing of spillovers: a case study of Swedish aircraft industry. In Pyka A. & Fonseca M.G.D. (eds.) Catching Up, Spillovers and Innovation Networks in a Schumpeterian Perspective. Springer.
Eliasson, G. (2017). Visible Costs and Invisible Benefits: Military Procurement as Innovation Policy. Springer International Publishing AG.
Etemadi, A. (2020). Buying for the Right Battle: Determining Defense Acquisition Strategies (Report No GWU-AM-21-002). Acquisition Research Program. https://dair.nps.edu/bitstream/123456789/4503/1/GWU-AM-21-002.pdf
Feickert A. (2011). Mine-Resistant, Ambush-Protected (MRAP) Vehicles: Background and Issues for Congress (Report No RS22707). Congressional Research Service. https://sgp.fas.org/crs/weapons/RS22707.pdf
Flood, R.L. & Romm N.R.A. (1996). Diversity Management: Triple-Loop Learning. Wiley.
Fonfría, A. & Sempere, C.M. (2020). The Spanish defence industry. In Hartley, K. (ed.) The Economics of the Global Defence Industry. Routledge.
Friedland, R. & Alford, R. R. (1991). Bringing society back in; Symbols, practice and institutional contradictions. In Powell, W. and DiMaggio, P. (eds.) The new institutionalism in organisational analysis. University of Chicago Press.
Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2020a). Technology Readiness Assessment Guide (Report No GAO-20-48G). Government Accountability Office. https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-20-48g.pdf
Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2020b). Defense Acquisitions Annual Assessment: Drive to Deliver Capabilities Faster Increases Importance of Program Knowledge and Consistent Data for Oversight (Report No GAO-20-439). Government Accountability Office. https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-20-439.pdf
Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2021). Weapon Systems Annual Assessment: Updated Program Oversight Approach Needed (Report No GAO-21-222). Government Accountability Office. https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-21-222.pdf
Government Accountability Office (GAO) (2022). Weapon Systems Annual Assessment: Challenges to Fielding Capabilities Faster Persist (Report No GAO-22-105230). Government Accountability Office. https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-22-105230.pdf
Güvenç S. & Yanik L.K. (2012). Turkey’s involvement in the F-35 program One step forward, two steps backward? International Journal, 68(1), 111-129.
Hartley, K. (2018). The Economics of European Defense Industrial Policy. In Karampekios, N., Olikonomou, I. & Carayannis, E.G. (eds.) The Emergence of EU Defense Research Policy. Springer International Publishing AG.
Hartley, K. (2020a). Defence Economics. Cambridge University Press.
Hartley, K. (2020b). NATO at 70: A Political Economy Perspective. Palgrave MacMillan.
Hartley, K. & Belin, J. (2020). The global defence industry: an overview. In Hartley, K. & Belin, J. (eds.) The Economics of the Global Defence Industry. Routledge.
Jones, S. J. (2022). Analysis of Cost and Schedule Estimation Trends for Major Defense Acquisition Programs [Master’s dissertation, Air Force Institute of Technology]. https://scholar.afit.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6402&context=etd
Kanniainen, V. & Lehtonen, J.M. (2020). Cooperative Procurement in Building National Defence: Why Are There So Few?. Defence and Peace Economics, 31(2). 201-219. https://doi.org/10.1080/10242694.2018.1471320
Kolb, D. A. (1984). Experiential Learning at the Source of Learning and Development. New Prentice Hall.
Lefeez, S. (2014). Représentations et usages des armements contemporains: Pour une socio-anthropologie de la complexité technique. [Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne]. https://www.theses.fr/2014PA010640
Lefeez, S. (2017a). Acquisition and Its Theoretical Foundations: A Phenomenon at the Crossroads of Phenomena. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Lefeez, S. (2017b). L’illusion technologique dans la pensée militaire. Nuvis.
Lewis, M.A. & Roehrich, J. (2009). Contracts, relationships and integration: towards a model of the procurement of complex performance. International Journal of Procurement Management, 2(2). 125-142. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJPM.2009.023403
Lopes Pimenta, M., Cezarino, L.O., Piato, E.L., Pinto da Silva, C.H., Garcia Oliveira, B. & Liboni, L.B. (2022). Supply chain resilience in a Covid-19 scenario: Mapping capabilities in a systemic framework. Sustainable Production and Consumption, 29(1). 649-656. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.10.012
Louth, J. (2010). A Low Dishonest Decade… Smart Acquisition and Defence Procurement into the New Millennium. [Doctoral dissertation, University of Wales Institute]. https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=737c62ec5b14c3700f48e0f33df10ceeab0c3aed
Markowski S., Hall, P. & Wylie, R. (2010). Procurement and the chain of supply. In Markowski S., Hall, P. & Wylie, R. (eds.) Defence Procurement and Industry Policy: A small country perspective. Routledge.
Markowski, S. & Hall, P. (2014). Mandated defence offsets: can they ever deliver?. Defense & Security Analysis, 30(2). 148-162. https://doi.org/10.1080/14751798.2014.894294
Matthews, R. (2014). The UK Offset Model: From Participation to Engagement (Whitehall Report 1-14). Royal United Services Institute (RUSI). https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/whitehall-reports/the-uk-offset-model-from-participation-to-engagement
McAvoy, D. (2017). Institutional Entrepreneurship in Defence Aquistion: What don’t’ we understand?. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
McGerty, F. (2021). Shift in default position: the United Kingdom’s Defence and Security Industrial Strategy 2021. Military Balance Bloc. https://www.iiss.org/blogs/military-balance/2021/04/uk-defence-and-security-industrial-strategy
Meyer, O.C., Bricknell, M. & Pacheco Padro R. (2021). How the COVID-19 crisis has affected security and defence-related aspects of the EU (Report No PE 653.623). Directorate General for External Policies of the European Union. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/IDAN/2021/653623/EXPO_IDA(2021)653623_EN.pdf
Ministry of Defence (MOD) (2021). Defence and Security Industrial Strategy: A strategic approach to the UK’s defence and security industrial sectors. Ministry of Defence. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/971983/Defence_and_Security_Industrial_Strategy_-_FINAL.pdf
Ministry of Defence (MOD) (2022). Joint Service Publication (JSP) 655 [V3.0 April 2022]. Knowledge in Defence (KID). Ministry of Defence. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/knowledge-in-defence-kid
Moore, D.M. (2017). Professionalism in Defence Acquistion: The Importance of Knowledge and the Concept of Intelligent Customer. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.). Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) (2022). Defence Expenditure of NATO Countries 2014-2022 (Press Release PR/CP(2022)105). North Atlantic Treaty Organisation. https://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/2022/6/pdf/220627-def-exp-2022-en.pdf
Neal, D.J. (2017). Defence Acquistion: A New Beast or a Dinosaur?. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.). Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
O’Reilly, C.A. & Tushman, M.L. (2013). Organizational Ambidexterity: Past, Present and Future. Academy of Management Perspectives, 27(4), 324-338.
Panwar, R., Pinkse, J. & De Marchi, V. (2022). The Future of Global Supply Chains in a Post-COVID-19 World. California Management Review, 64(2). 5-23. https://doi.org/10.1177/00081256211073355
Pennock, M.J. (2008). The Economics of Enterprise Transformation: An Analysis of the Defense Acquisition System [Doctoral Thesis, Georgia Institute of Technology]. https://smartech.gatech.edu/bitstream/handle/1853/28171/pennock_michael_j_200805_phd.pdf
Pennock, M.J. (2015). Defense acquisition: a tragedy of the commons. Systems Engineering, 18(4). 349-364. https://doi.org/10.1002/sys.21308
Petrelli, N. (2020). Military Innovation and Defence Acquisition: Lessons from the F-35 Programme. IAI Papers, 20(1). 1-20.
Popper, K. (1961). The Logic of Scientific Discovery. Science Editions.
Porter, M. (1985). The competitive advantage: Creating and sustaining superior performance. The Free Press.
Rendon, R. G. & Snider, K. F. (2019). Management of Defense Acquisition Projects. Second Edition. American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc.
Reykers, R.F. (2021). Strengthening parliamentary oversight of defence procurement: lessons from Belgium. European Security, 30(4). 505-525. https://doi.org/10.1080/09662839.2021.1886087
Roehrich J.K., Caldwell, N.D. & Lewis, M.A. (2014). Procuring complex performance in the UK defense sector. In Essig, M. & Glas A.H. (eds.) Performance Based Logistics: Innovatives Beschaffungsmanagement für die Streitkräfte. Springer Fachmedien.
Rubel, R.C. (2011). The Future of The Future of Aircraft Carriers. Naval War College Review, 64(4). 13-27.
Rittel, H. & Webber, M. (1973). Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences, 4(1). 155-169.
Smith, R.P. (2022). Defence Acquisition and Procurement: How (Not) to Buy Weapons. Cambridge University Press.
Snider, K.F. (2017). Defence Acquisition, Public Administration, and Pragmatism. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Stockholm International Peace Institute (SIPRI) (2022). The SIPRI Top 100 Arms-producing and Military Services Companies 2021 (SIPRI Fact Sheet). Stockholm International Peace Institute. https://doi.org/10.55163/VYJC8517
Šumpíková, M. & Ďurčeková I. (2019). Transaction Costs, Outsourcing, and the Public Procurement Review Process in the Czech Republic and Slovakia. The NISPAcee Journal of Public Administration and Policy, 12(2). 233-250. https://doi.org/10.2478/nispa-2019-0021
Taylor, T. (2017). Competition in Defence Practice: Theory and Reality. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Teece, D.J., Pisano, G. & Shuen, A. (1997). Dynamic capabilities and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 8(7). 509-533.
Tian, N. (2020). The inter-relation between arms trade, military expenditure and armed conflict. In Tan, A. (ed.) Research Handbook on the Arms Trade. Edward Elgar.
Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment (USDA&S) (2022). State of Competition within the Defense Industrial Base (Working Report). Department of Defense https://media.defense.gov/2022/Feb/15/2002939087/-1/-1/1/STATE-OF-COMPETITION-WITHIN-THE-DEFENSE-INDUSTRIAL-BASE.PDF
Uttley, M. (2018). Arms Procurement. In Meijer, H. & Wyss, M. (eds.) The Handbook of European Defence Policies and Armed Forces. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198790501.003.0040
Van Strien, J., Gelderman, C.J. & Semeijn, J. (2019). Performance-based contracting in military supply chains and the willingness to bear risks. Journal of Defense Analytics and Logistics, 3(1). 83-107. https://doi.org/10.1108/JDAL-10-2017-0021
Van Weele, A.J. & Essig, M. (2017). Strategische Beschaffung: Grundlagen, Planung und Umsetzung eines integrierten Supply Management. Springer Gabler.
Verlaine, A. (2022a). An empirical analysis of the Luxembourg post-Cold War defence expenditure. Intellectual Economics, 16(2). 189–217.
Verlaine, A. (2022b). Defense Acquisition and Small NATO Nations: Learning from the Not-For-Profit Sector and Its Effectiveness Strategies. Organizational Cultures: An International Journal, 22(1). 103-113. https://doi.org/10.18848/2327-8013/CGP/v22i01/103-113
Verlaine, A. (in press-a). Transaction costs and architectural complexity in no-capability defence acquisition. International Journal of Procurement Management. http://doi.org/10.1504/IJPM.2022.10049042
Verlaine, A. (in press-b). No-capability defence acquisition: a literature review on policy and practice of military acquisition within NATO and the EU. International Journal of Procurement Management. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJPM.2021.10045018
Wong, J.P., Younossi, O., Kistler LaCoste, C., Anton, P.S., Vick, A.J., Weichenberg, G. & Whitmore, T.C. (2022). Improving Defense Acquisition: Insights from Three Decades of RAND Research (Research Report No RR-A1670-1). RAND Corporation. https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/RRA1600/RRA1670-1/RAND_RRA1670-1.pdf
Wylie, R.C. (2017). Defence Procurement, Innovation and Value for Money. In Burgess, K. & Antill, P. (eds.) Emerging Strategies in Defense Acquisitions and Military Procurement. IGI Global.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Alexandre Verlaine
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
